8/8/03
Energy Distribution in Iraq
The news today (NPR
Morning Edition , CSM
yesterday) described some of the difficulties in restoring
reliable power to Baghdad and other areas of Iraq. The prediction
was that it might take over a year. The issue is not in power generation,
and certainly not in fuel, but in distribution. The major distribution
lines had been disrupted (either during the main battles between
Iraqi and "coalition" forces or by saboteurs).
This is a clear illustration of the vulnerability of centralized
power generation. After the WTC bombings of 9/11/01, many energy
activists noted that our energy systems were too reliant on large,
centralized power generators that could make attractive targets
for terrorists. Members of the Bush Administration (and their allies
in the oil and nuclear power industries) have ignored this vulnerability
here at home.
The situation in Iraq provides us with an opportunity to demonstrate
a safer alternative. If disrupted power distribution from centralized
generators is the problem, then decentralization is the solution.
Small-scale, neighborhood generation and interconnected distribution
networks are much less vulnerable. One of the drawbacks of localized
power generation is the noise and pollution associated with fossil-fuel
generators (even on a small scale). So, while such generators are
reliable and practical as back-up systems (especially where petroleum
products are plentiful), they are not considered a desirable feature
of residential and commercial neighborhoods. Even in Baghdad, constant
use of such generators should be limited to industrial areas where
noise and pollution are somewhat less problematic. In the places
where people live, shop, or work in offices, alternative
technologies are preferable.
It would seem that photovoltaic solar panels are an ideal energy
solution for most of Iraq. The newly solarized
West Marine store in Santa Cruz exemplifies the potential of
this model of energy production. The unfortunate crisis in Iraq
has left us a wonderful opportunity to model appropriate, decentralized
energy options. It would probably be no more expensive than reconstructing
the traditional centralized infrastructure, it could be deployed
to more critical areas on a priority basis, and it would be much
less vulnerable to disruption while the situation in Iraq remains
unstable. As an added benefit to the Iraqi people, they would use
less of their petroleum "cash crop" at home, allowing them to profit
through trade with the US and other less fortunate countries still
dependent on petroleum. Most important to the people of the US and
the rest of the world, it would serve as a model and testing ground
for alternative energy generation and distribution.
I wrote my senators and representative in Washington on this issue.
Here is a model letter, and here is
a website that helps in contacting
the congress.
8/18/03
Blackout Update
There are many things that can be said about the recent
blackout in the northeastern US and Canada. Many have focused
on deregulation,
including Greg
Palast. Others have focused on climate change, or the lack of
adequate conservation measures. I find it interesting that it comes
so close on the heels of my previous blog (above),
and Amory
Lovins, Harvey
Wasserman and Jeremy
Rifkin have made connections to many of the issues that concerned
me.
For a better understanding of the vulnerability of centralized
power networks, you might want to read the first chapter of the
excellent book Six
Degrees: The Science of a Connected Age
by Duncan J. Watts. It describes a similar cascade of small
failures and coincidences in the west in 1996. These situations
brilliantly illustrate the sometimes ominous nature of interconnected,
complex systems. Small disturbances usually lead to only small failures,
but occasionally (especially when the system is already under a
lot of stress) a small failure can trigger widespread catastrophe.
This is one of the scariest aspects of biodiversity loss and climate
change, two phenomena that are represented by complex, interconnected
systems currently under a great deal of stress. I'm gonna go get
some chocolate and St. John's wort now, and try to stop twisting
my hair and chewing my lip. I'm sure it's all gonna be just fine.